Skip to main content

Panel discussion questions: 30 to ask panelists, plus audience Q&A

By Alan Magliocca

Quick answer: Good panel discussion questions run from broad to specific: a baseline question, then experience, disagreement, specifics and application, ending with a lightning round. Give each panelist a different question at the same difficulty instead of asking everyone the same one. For audience Q&A, allow anonymous questions and upvotes, answer the top ones live and keep real backup questions ready.

KEY TAKEAWAYS
  • Prepare at least two main questions per panelist and a backup set of ten or more.
  • Order questions from broad to specific, and put a disagreement question in the middle.
  • Give each panelist a different question; save same-question rounds for the lightning round.
  • For audience Q&A, allow anonymous questions and upvotes, and dismiss rather than delete.
  • Collect a question on the registration form so your backup is a real attendee question.

Why the questions decide the panel

Panelists bring knowledge; the questions decide whether any of it reaches the audience. Kristin Arnold's guidance for Toastmasters on virtual panels sets a useful bar: at least two main questions per panelist, a backup set of 10 or more, and an order that runs from broad, strategic questions to benefits, then specifics, then application (Toastmasters Magazine).

She also prefers "ping-pong" to "hot potato." Ping-pong gives each panelist a different question at the same level of difficulty. Hot potato sends the same question down the line, and by the third panelist you hear "I agree with everything that's been said." Use hot potato only for the lightning round, where short and repeated is the point.

30 panel discussion questions, in the order you'd ask them

Replace the brackets with your topic and your panelists' seats.

Baseline: open with one of these

  1. "When people say [topic], what do they usually get wrong?"
  2. "What changed in [field] recently that this audience may have missed?"
  3. "In one sentence, where do you stand on [the central question]?"
  4. "Which part of this problem do you see up close every day?"

Experience

  1. "Tell us about the moment you changed your mind about [topic]."
  2. "What did you do first that didn't work?"
  3. "Who taught you the thing you rely on most?"
  4. "What does a bad week look like from your seat?"

Disagreement: the reason to have a panel at all

  1. "[Name] just said X. Where would you push back?"
  2. "What common advice in [field] would you tell people to ignore?"
  3. "If you had to bet on one approach, which one, and why not the other?"
  4. "What does [the other panelist's seat: the buyer, the lender, the regulator] misunderstand about your side?"
  5. "You two disagree on this. Let's hear both cases."

Specifics

  1. "Walk us through the first step, as if we start on Monday."
  2. "What does this cost in time, not money, to get right?"
  3. "What do you track to know it's working?"
  4. "What's the early warning sign that it's going wrong?"
  5. "Which tool or habit would you refuse to give up?"

Application

  1. "What changes if someone here has a team of five instead of fifty?"
  2. "What should a person starting from nothing do this week?"
  3. "What would you say to someone who attempted this and failed?"
  4. "Which mistake here is expensive, and which is cheap?"

Lightning round: 30 seconds each, same question to everyone

  1. "One word for where [field] is heading."
  2. "The best resource you used this year: a book, a person or a tool?"
  3. "One thing you'd stop doing tomorrow."
  4. "Myth or fact: [a claim your audience believes]?"

Closing

  1. "What should I have asked that I didn't?"
  2. "What's one thing you want people here to do next?"
  3. "What did another panelist say today that you'll borrow?"
  4. "Where can people follow your work?"

Panel discussion questions and answers: running audience Q&A

Audience questions are where a panel earns the word "discussion." Here is a setup on Zoom Webinars, taken from Zoom's own article on webinar Q&A (Zoom Support).

  1. Before the event, set the options. Turn on anonymous questions, which hides the asker's name from the host, co-hosts and panelists. Let attendees view all questions, which is what allows upvoting and comments. Zoom Q&A needs a licensed host with the Webinar add-on.
  2. Sort by upvotes. Sorting by Most Upvotes needs host or panelist Q&A version 5.8.6 or higher, so check versions in rehearsal.
  3. Answer live, then mark it. The moderator reads the question aloud and names who answers first. When a panelist answers out loud, the host or a co-host can click Done for them, so the producer keeps the queue clean.
  4. Type the factual ones. Links, dates and "where do I find that" questions get a typed answer, which keeps airtime for questions that need discussion.
  5. Answer personal ones privately. "Can I qualify if..." questions about someone's own situation go to Answer Privately with a contact.
  6. Dismiss, don't delete. Dismissed questions can be reopened; deleted ones can't.
  7. Mind the rooms. Q&A can't be used inside webinar breakout rooms.
  8. Afterward, pull the report. Generate the Q&A report and answer whatever you missed in the follow-up email.

Two routing rules keep it moving: no more than two panelists answer any audience question, and the moderator rewords long questions into one sentence before reading them. Group repeats out loud: "Three of you asked about hiring, so this one's for everyone."

When nobody asks anything

Joel Schwartzberg's moderator guide for Toastmasters suggests counting silently to five after inviting questions, then moving to a backup question (Toastmasters Magazine). A better backup is a real one: add an optional "What's your biggest question about this?" field to the registration form and keep three of the answers on your card. Read them as what they are: "One of you asked this when you registered."

Engagement beyond the Q&A box

  • Poll, then hand it to a panelist. "Most of you said cash flow. Luis, is that what you'd have guessed?" A poll result is only engaging when someone reacts to it.
  • Pick-a-side in chat. At the disagreement question, ask the audience to type A for one panelist's view and B for the other's, then read the split aloud.
  • A closing poll: "Which panelist changed your mind about something?" It's light, and it tells you whom to invite back.

For poll and chat mechanics across platforms, see virtual event engagement.

Worked example: a chamber of commerce panel on a second location

This is a made-up example. The Ridgeway Chamber of Commerce runs a 50-minute panel: "Opening a second location: three owners who did it, and a lender who's seen it go wrong." Panelists: a bakery owner, a physical therapy clinic owner, an auto repair shop owner and a small-business lender from a community bank.

  • Baseline, to the lender: "What do owners get wrong when they ask for expansion financing?"
  • Disagreement, to the bakery and auto repair owners: "Same neighborhood or a new town for location two?" They chose differently, which is why they were booked.
  • Specifics, to the clinic owner: "Who ran location one while you were opening location two?"
  • Lightning round: "One thing you'd do before signing the lease."
  • Audience Q&A: anonymous questions and upvotes on. The top-voted question is about hiring a site manager. Questions about a specific loan get a private answer with the lender's contact.
  • Silence at the start of Q&A: the moderator counts to five, then reads a question from the registration form.
  • After: the Q&A report feeds a short follow-up in the chamber's newsletter.

Costs and time

  • Writing questions: about 90 minutes for two per panelist plus ten backups.
  • Q&A setup: about 15 minutes in webinar settings, plus checking versions in rehearsal.
  • People: one person on the Q&A queue for the full hour.
  • With BrightStage AI: a chat assistant answers routine attendee questions in the event chat, such as how to join or where the replay is, leaving real questions for the panel. "Suggest" buttons fill event fields for 1 credit per click. For other software options, see AI tools for hosting virtual events.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Hot potato on every question. The last panelist has nothing new to say.
  • Yes-or-no questions, which end in one word.
  • Two-part questions, where panelists answer only the easier half.
  • Reading names on sensitive questions. Keep those anonymous.
  • The moderator answering audience questions. Your job is to route them.

To place these questions in the hour, use the virtual panel agenda. The lines that frame them are in the virtual panel script.

How BrightStage AI fits

BrightStage AI, a webinar and live-event platform from Podavinci LLC, puts engagement in the event chat: a chat assistant answers attendees, review cards collect testimonials in chat, and sale announcements show only real purchases. Replays, called "Encore", let people who missed the live panel catch up. Its listed features don't include upvoted Q&A like Zoom's, so if your panel depends on audience voting, plan the Q&A on a platform that has it.

Sources

AIVX LABS ACCOUNT VERIFICATION
Get AIVX Labs verified for $1: RICO, your AI operator, and 35+ AI tools, with 7 days of full access.
Get AIVX Labs Verified for $1 →

Frequently asked questions

What are good questions to ask a panel?

Start with a baseline question everyone can answer, then ask about experience, where panelists disagree, specific steps and how the audience can apply it. Close with a lightning round.

How do you handle panel discussion questions and answers from the audience?

Collect questions in a Q&A tool, read each aloud in one sentence, name who answers first and limit each question to two panelists.

How many questions should a moderator prepare for a panel?

Toastmasters guidance suggests at least two main questions per panelist plus ten or more backups.

What if the audience doesn't ask any questions?

Count silently to five, then use a backup. The best backups are real questions collected on the registration form.

Related playbooks

Written by Alan Magliocca, founder of BrightStage AI and AIVX Labs (Podavinci LLC). Written with AI assistance and checked against the linked sources. Follow along: LinkedIn · YouTube · TikTok · X · Facebook · Instagram · Skool community